Not What We Were Hoodie
Not What We Were Hoodie
Not What We Were Hoodie
Not What We Were Hoodie Girl
Not What We Were Hoodie Black
Not What We Were Hoodie Back

Not What We Were Hoodie

Regular price $44.99
Sale price $44.99 Regular price

Season 3, Episode Two gives us a case of mistaken identity. The disciples are completely baffled when Jesus pairs up Matthew and Simon Z. for a mission. A tax collector and a zealot. A traitor and an ultranationalist. The two of them together just don’t add up.

View Size Chart
Product Details

But Jesus solves the matter easily. Matthew’s not a tax collector, and Zee’s not a Zealot. That’s only what they used to be. “None of you is what you were,” he tells them.  “Remember that, all of you.”

This hoodie is a simple way to remember our true identity—and tell others, too.

Product Details:

  • Adult and Youth sizes 
  • 7 oz.
  • 52% Airlume combed and ringspun cotton
  • 48% polyester fleece
  • White cord drawstring
  • Ribbed cuffs and waistband
  • Front pouch pocket

Note: If a product says unavailable, it refers specifically to a size and color. Other sizes/colors may be available.

Please double-check sizing prior to completing your order.  

Shipping Details

All orders are processed within 2-3 business days.

Orders are not shipped or delivered on weekends or holidays.

If we are experiencing a high volume of orders, shipments may be delayed by a few days.

Please allow additional days in transit for delivery. 

If there will be a significant delay in the shipment of your order, we will contact you via email with additional information.

The Chosen Gifts Size Guide

Youth Basic Hoodie

Size Chest Body Length
Sleeve Length
16 1/2 in
21 1/2
17 1/2
18 1/2


Adult Basic Hoodie

Size Chest Body Length
Sleeve Length
S 19.5 in 26.5
26 in
21.5 in
27.5 in
27 in
23.5 in
28.5 in
28 in
25.5 in
29.5 in
29 in
27.5 in
31 in
30 in
29.5 in
31.5 in
30.5 in
31.5 in
32 in
31 in
33.5 in
32 in
31 in


Customer Reviews

Based on 188 reviews
Lauren A.H.
NOT what We Were Hoodie

I ordered an XL but a 2XL was in the package instead. Gave it to my grandson and he loved it. Really soft.

Chrissy S. (Central Islip, US)
Love this

Absolutely love this sweatshirt. Just as I love all my others. This one was a little smaller than my other ones so I got the next size up, and I’m so thankful.
No shame. Not what I was. Jesus changed all of that. Thank you for all you do, and making an impact on our family.


I absolutely love the sweatshirts from the chosen. This is one of my favorites. The messages on the front take me back to the episode where the words were actually used and they generate conversation from others. I’m pretty sure that’s what’s known as a win-win!!!

Melissa V. (Christiansburg, US)
Not What We Were

Absolutely Love this hoodie. I am a recovering Alcoholic and this hoodie explains my continuous transformation and God is the Potter

Timothy H. (San Jose, US)
Perfect for my wife

She got the color she wanted and the message she wants to declare to the world and we're supporting the spread of the much needed gospel.